CNN’s Dana Bash Pushes Back on Mike Rogers’ Claim That Abdul El-Sayed “Didn’t Disavow” the Muslim Brotherhood
Meta description: On CNN’s State of the Union, Dana Bash challenged Mike Rogers’ claim that Abdul El-Sayed never disavowed the Muslim Brotherhood. Here’s what was said, what the video shows, and what both sides argue.
The Michigan Senate race, one of the closest of the 2026 midterms, produced a heated television exchange on Sunday, October 18. Republican nominee Mike Rogers appeared on CNN’s State of the Union, and host Dana Bash pushed back on his claim that Democratic nominee Abdul El-Sayed “didn’t disavow” the Muslim Brotherhood.
What Happened at the Town Hall
The dispute began a day earlier, at an El-Sayed town hall. An attendee asked him to disavow the Muslim Brotherhood, and El-Sayed answered, “Sure. Yes, absolutely.” Reporting on the full exchange adds more context. El-Sayed also said that the question itself assumes he might have dual loyalties or an allegiance higher than the Constitution. CNNdailykos
The CNN Exchange
On the CNN interview, Bash played the town hall video and noted that El-Sayed had said yes. Rogers disagreed. He insisted El-Sayed hadn’t disavowed the group and accused him of deflecting with a “word salad.” Bash held her ground. She repeated the words El-Sayed actually used and said she only wanted to stay factual. CNN’s Dana Bash Throws Down With GOP Candidate Mike Rogers About Trump Calling El-Sayed a ‘Jihadist’ +2
Rogers’ fuller argument, as published by his campaign, is that the answer wasn’t enough. He said El-Sayed didn’t say “no” or address the group’s views on women’s roles, and that his opponent “won’t and can’t” disavow it. Rogers also said his objection is about ideology, not El-Sayed’s faith. He questioned why the press seemed so eager to protect his opponent. MIKE ROGERS ON CNN: ABDUL WON’T AND CAN’T DISAVOW THE MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD — Mike Rogers for Senate +2
The interview also covered another flashpoint. Bash asked about President Trump calling El-Sayed a “jihadist,” and Rogers said the president will do what he’s going to do. CNN
The Wider Context
This was not the first time the Brotherhood issue came up in the race.
- The allegation: Rogers has said El-Sayed pledged support to the Muslim Brotherhood. Bridge Michigan’s fact-check found that he did not, including in a 2012 letter defending then-Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi. bridgemi
- The denial: On NBC’s Meet the Press, El-Sayed said neither he nor his family has ties to the Brotherhood. jewishinsider
- The family angle: The Washington Free Beacon reported on old social media posts by El-Sayed’s half-sister claiming long-standing family ties to the group. The same report states there is no evidence El-Sayed was personally involved. nbcmontanaabcnews4
- The designation: In January, the U.S. designated the Egyptian branch of the Muslim Brotherhood as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist organization. bridgemi
Two Readings of the Same Moment
Supporters of El-Sayed say the video speaks for itself. He was asked to disavow the group, and he said yes. They see Rogers’ continued claim as a political attack that ignores the evidence, and some call the line of attack Islamophobic.
Supporters of Rogers say the question is fair and the answer was incomplete. They argue that a candidate whose relatives have been linked to the group should address it clearly and in detail. Conservative outlets criticized Bash’s handling of the interview, claiming she kept steering the conversation back to Trump. Left-leaning outlets, meanwhile, framed her pushback as a straightforward fact-check.
The Bottom Line
The factual core is narrow. At the town hall, El-Sayed was asked whether he would disavow the Muslim Brotherhood, and he answered yes. What remains in dispute is whether that answer was sufficient, and how much weight voters should give to the surrounding questions about his family and associations. With the race this tight, expect the argument to continue until Election Day.
Sources worth reading: CNN’s State of the Union segment (cnn.com), Bridge Michigan’s fact-check (bridgemi.com), Mediaite’s recap of the interview (mediaite.com), Jewish Insider on El-Sayed’s Meet the Press interview (jewishinsider.com), and Rogers’ campaign statement (rogersforsenate.com).
